Skip to main content

Full text of "[untitled] The American Historical Review, (1920-10-01), pages 116-117"

See other formats


Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World 

This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in 
the world by JSTOR. 

Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other 
writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the 
mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. 

We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this 
resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial 

Read more about Early Journal Content at 
journal-content . 

JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people 
discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching 
platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit 
organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please 

n6 Reviews of Books 

in so doing Mr. Ogg thinks he broke new ground. He " reshaped men's 
conception of the presidency and helped make that office the power that 
it is to-day" (p. 236). 

In Mr. Ogg's volume the honest, virile, irascible, chivalric, iron- 
willed, patriotic " General " Jackson and his battles with Indians, law- 
breakers, red-coats, nullifiers, aristocrats, John Adams, John Marshall, 
and the Whigs stand out in fresh and strong lines again. 

D. R. Anderson. 

The Conquest of the Old Southwest: the Romantic Story of the 
Early Pioneers into Virginia, the Carolinas, Tennessee, and Ken- 
tucky, 1740-1790. By Archibald Henderson, Ph.D., D.C.L. 
(New York: Century Company. 1920. Pp. xxiv, 395. $2.50.) 
One expects from Mr. Henderson a well-told story, and this volume 
realizes this expectation. In about four hundred pages there has been 
condensed a narrative of- the advance of the Americans into the region 
of the southwest, particularly into Tennessee, that will interest the 
scientific historian as well as the lay reader. 

This general praise of the book calls for the establishment of very 
definite limitations. Although in his title and subtitle Mr. Henderson 
claims to have covered the whole Old Southwest with the possible ex- 
ception of lands bordering the Gulf, he has in general centred his narra- 
tive around two events, the Transylvania Company enterprise and the 
Revolutionary War in the modern state of Tennessee. The years and 
the territory lying just outside of the time and scene of these events 
have received scant treatment. The westward push of the Virginians 
into Kentucky, the intrigues of the land speculators, the question of the 
provincial soldiers' rights, the significance of the laying out of Louisville 
— this last event not even being mentioned — the claim of the Indiana 
Company in modern West Virginia, are all granted inadequate treat- 
ment. The Vandalia Company, around which played so much politics 
both in America and in the mother country, receives only half a page, 
whereas to the Transylvania Company are devoted two chapters without 
counting the two others depicting the activities of the company's agent, 
Daniel Boone. The struggle of Tennessee for statehood is treated at 
length, whereas the equally important effort on the pan of Kentucky is 
granted a few paragraphs. Very significant events affecting the Old 
Southwest were taking place during these years in West Florida, but 
the name of that colony does not appear in the index. 

Mr. Henderson adds another, authority to be quoted in favor of the 
popular apotheosis of Daniel Boone, to whose story he devotes two 
chapters full of eulogy. Boone has been fortunate in his biographers, 
who have told his story in such a way that popular fancy has pictured 
him as the first man to visit the blue-grass region of Kentucky. Mr. 
Henderson, himself, names many who had preceded this doughty hunter, 

Skinner: Adventurers of Oregon 117 

but by no means all. From the end of the seventeenth century French 
and American hunting parties were frequent visitors to Kentucky and 
Tennessee, and had been so successful that it was said in 1767 that the 
game there was scarce. By 1768 the whole region was fairly well known 
to many English-speaking visitors and hundreds of boatmen had floated 
on the Ohio past its shores. Mr. Henderson mentions a few voyages 
(p. 120) and dismisses them with the following, "though interesting 
enough in themselves, [they] had little bearing upon the larger phases 
of westward expansion ". 

There are a few errors in the book that should be noted. Celoron de 
Blainville, and not Celeron de Bienville, was the French officer who was 
sent in to the Ohio valley in 1748. The Cherokee were never so favor- 
able to the French as is stated on page 49. The traditional interpreta- 
tion of the importance of Governor Spotswood's expedition to the moun- 
tains is retained. It is not yet proved that the British in the Northwest 
offered bounties for American scalps (p. 261). Unfortunately a line or 
more has been dropped by printer's carelessness at the bottom of page 
193 ; aside from this, the bo'ok is very free from typographical errors. 

From what has been said it is evident that there are grave limita- 
tions to Mr. Henderson's interpretation of Old Southwest history; but 
if the reader is interested in the Watauga settlement, in the Transyl- 
vania experiment, in the battle of King's Mountain, in the Indian wars 
of Tennessee, in the abortive attempt to establish the state of Franklin, 
and in a fine interpretation of the character and spirit of the frontiers- 
men, he will find the narrative very valuable. 

C. W. Alvord. 

Adventurers of Oregon: a Chronicle of the Fur Trade. By Con- 
stance L. Skinner. [Chronicles of America series, vol. XXII.] 
(New Haven: Yale University Press. 1920. Pp. x, 290.) 
This book is a delight. The author treats the dramatic scenes and 
incidents in the background of Oregon's history, achieving therein a 
wholly unusual degree of literary perfection. Thus she has produced a 
narrative which, for adult readers, deserves to take very high rank in 
its special field. That field the subtitles, eight in number, help to define 
although each of these again calls for some analysis. The titles are: 
the River of the West, Lewis and Clark, the Reign of the Trapper, the 
Tonquin, Astor's Overlanders, Astoria under the Nor'westers, and the 
King of Old Oregon. The period covered is from the beginnings of 
exploration to the settlement of the Oregon boundary dispute in 1846, 
and the themes represented by the above chapter-heads are essentially 
two — Discovery and Exploration, and the Fur-Trade. 

In her treatment the author exhibits a good knowledge of the facts, 
a comprehension of relations, critical insight, and a mastery of artistic 
arrangement rarely excelled. Her critical acumen is manifested not